Voices from States and Administrative Areas
Policy actions to strengthen Public Finance Management in South Sudan
November 1, 2024
South Sudan, a developing nation with nascent institutions and limited human resources capacity, is experiencing its worst economic crisis since gaining independence in 2011. Improving service delivery in this context requires effective public financial management systems.
In the third quarter of 2024, UNDP, funded by the African Development Bank (AfDB) through the Institutional Support Project for Strengthening Economic Governance in South Sudan, organized capacity-building workshops in all states and administrative areas. These workshops aimed to enhance the government's policy and technical capacities around revenue mobilization, budget processes, and legislative oversight. Under the facilitation of UNDP’s Economic Governance Analysts, the workshops provided a platform for subnational governments and stakeholders to learn about and share experiences regarding tax revenue policies, budget frameworks, and legislative oversight to ensure a prudent economic management process. The workshops also identified capacity gaps and provided policy options and recommendations on critical issues.
The events convened senior government officials including governors, ministers, government advisors, members of parliament, commissioner generals of revenue authorities, directors of audit chambers, ministry director generals and directors, and senior officials from municipal councils, as well as youth and women’s groups. The aim of these events is to strengthen economic institutions at the subnational level to serve as catalysts for addressing public financial management and sustainable development challenges.
Background Context
South Sudan is facing an enormous economic crisis due to internal conflicts, floods, and external factors such as wars in Ukraine, Sudan, and the Middle East, which have disrupted supply chains and led to macroeconomic instability. A recent pipeline breakdown disrupted oil production, significantly reducing government revenues and presenting a substantial fiscal challenge to the national budget, whose deficit is estimated at around 50% for FY 2024/2025. The oil sector initially accounted for 98% of total revenues, 95% of total exports, and 75% of GDP as of 2023. The reduction in oil revenues during FY 2023/2024 has correspondingly decreased transfers to states and administrative areas, which have struggled for many years to raise sufficient non-oil revenues to finance their budgets due to inadequate capacity and a fragmented tax system. This situation has affected service provision and exacerbated poverty levels and food insecurity. Additionally, most states and administrative areas have not been preparing their annual budgets in a transparent, comprehensive, and accountable manner. Budgets were signed into law without legislative oversight and citizen participation. Furthermore, both states and administrative areas lacked adequate policy and technical capacity to manage economic functions, undermining progress towards recovery, resilience, and development.
Against this backdrop, the series of workshops aimed to strengthen the human capacity of economic institutions, review past policy issues, guide budget preparation at the local level, identify challenges, and propose actionable solutions and recommendations aimed at enhancing non-oil revenue mobilization, budget processes, and legislative oversight. The overall objective of the workshops was to provide a catalytic platform and process to fast-track economic governance reforms at the subnational levels.
Workshop Categories
Taxation unification and revenue mobilization
To harmonize the tax system and strengthen technical capacities to optimize non-oil revenue mobilization, three-day tax policy dialogues and trainings were organized in Warrap, Western Bahr el Ghazal, Northern Bahr el Ghazal, Lakes, Eastern Equatoria, Jonglei and Unity States, and Ruweng Administrative Area. In each of the state and administrative area, at least 50 government officials were trained, except in Warrap (90) and Eastern Equatoria (102), where significantly high numbers of officials attended. The workshop served as a platform to accelerate the eradication of the overlapping tax jurisdictions, ensuring fairness, transparency, and efficiency in tax collection. The workshop also emphasized the need to streamline tax laws, rates, and procedures, reducing the risk of double taxation, and providing clarity for taxpayers. It further highlighted that improving revenue mobilization would accelerate implementation of state/area development plans.
Budget processes
To strengthen capacities for budget processes and fiscal mobilization and management, several officials from the spending agencies in Upper Nile State (70), Central Equatoria (50), Greater Pibor Administrative Area (50) and Western Equatoria State (60) were convened for a three-day workshop in each state. In Upper Nile State, participants were trained on payroll management (South Sudan’s Electronic Payroll System), budget execution, and public procurement) and national financial legislations. The workshops were also to prepare agencies for the budget process in FY 2024/2025 and to address issues such as the salary increment and resource allocation which came up during FY 2023/2024 especially in Greater Pibor Administrative Area.
Legislative oversight functions
To enhance legislative council’s ability to oversee financial matters, promoting transparency, civil society participation and accountability in fiscal policy and the budget process, UNDP in collaboration with the governments trained 50 MPs and senior government officials in Abyei Special Administrative Area and 100 MPs in Western Equatoria State on the annual budget process and financial scrutiny and audits. In Western Equatoria, a two-day fiscal year 2024/2025 budget preparation orientation workshop was also conducted for 60 participants comprising Director Generals, Directors for planning and budgeting, County Executive Directors, and county planners.
Lessons learned and key challenges
A few lessons were drawn from the workshops which included:
Several challenges persist in tax administration, including lack of electronic equipment for the Electronic Payroll System, concurrent tax powers on Personal Income Tax, exercise tax and royalties, E-Tax System, illegal checkpoints, and a lack of well-educated, well-trained, and well-resourced rate collectors.
The informal economy and government's financial limitations make it difficult to obtain reliable statistics, and income distribution is uneven.
Persistent insecurity in the country including the war in Sudan continues to disrupt supply chains, leading to increase prices, dual fees payments, and revenue loss.
Poor governance, corruption, mismanagement of public financial resources, and communal conflicts further hinder public service delivery.
Poor infrastructure across the country increases business costs and further hinders effective delivery of public services.
Overlapping tax jurisdictions between South Sudan Revenue Authority (SSRA) and State Revenue Authority (SRA) lead to confusion, compliance burdens, and revenue loss.
States and administrative areas continue to rely heavily on oil revenues transfers from the national government, which makes them vulnerable to global oil price fluctuations.
Limited collaboration persists between the executive and the state legislative assemblies on budget processes, financial reporting, and civil service appointments.
Low capacity of SSRA's revenue officers, SRA's tax rate collectors and County Development Committee (CDC) members in Public Financial Management (PFM) across states and counties.
Key resolutions and recommendations
The workshops’ deliberations resulted in several resolutions as follows:
Taxation unification:
Encouraged state and administrative area governments to strengthen interstate coordination mechanisms and leveraging the support of the national government to eradicate all illegal checkpoints.
Recommended subnational governments to pass legislative statutes, promulgating revenue authorities as independent bodies responsible for collection and administration of all revenues and enforcement of all revenue laws in the states and administrative areas.
Encouraged development partners to support the modernization/electronification of revenue authorities to ensure efficiency, transparency and accountability in collection and administration of all revenues.
SSRA and revenue generating institutions to establish a taxpayer-friendly approach to replace tax competition with tax jurisdictions and harmonization to ensure proper collection of income taxes across states and counties.
Expand the tax revenue bases/sources to include introduction of rental charges and fees for conversion of residential areas into investment and business zones, renewal fees on expired land leases, licenses, and health inspection fees on commercial livestock.
Continue providing institutional capacity building training to revenue generating institutions and extend the training programmes to the SRA’s tax rate collectors and County Development Committee (CDC) at county levels.
Budget process
Encouraged strict adherence to the budget calendar, processes, mechanisms, and guidelines to ensure transparency and accountability in the budget process.
Urged all governments to institutionalize the Single Treasury Account (STA) – Consolidated Block Account at the BoSS, with sub-accounts for spending agencies for printing of financial forms were established in all states and administrative areas, with a focus on tracking and proper supply distribution.
Legislative oversight
Encouraged a strict adherence to the right procedures for loans/borrowing in a transparent and accountable manner including seeking the mandates of the state legislature.
Capacitating the state audit chamber to enhance monitoring, transparency, and accountability in public spendingto improve the working conditions of the state legislature by providing good facilities to keep the MPs engaged and legislatures opened throughout the year.
The capacity building workshops in the states and administrative areas of South Sudan not only facilitated effective knowledge transfer but also ensured that the participants had a strong voice in shaping the resolutions and recommendations aimed at improving revenue mobilization, budget process and legislative oversight of fiscal policies for improved service delivery and accelerated progress towards sustainable development. The training enhanced the ability of these officers to influence revenue collection both collectively and individually.
UNDP remains committed to facilitating such initiatives, leveraging its expertise, and working closely with all governments and stakeholders on sustainable economic governance issues to strengthen national resilience, recovery, and economic transformation.